Sarah Palin Information Blog

Sarah Palin Web Brigade

  • Upcoming Palin Events

  • Sarah Palin’s Endorsees

  • Sarah Palin Channel

  • Amazing America

  • The Undefeated

  • ‘Stars Earn Stripes’

  • ‘Game Change’ Lies Exposed

  • Good Tidings and Great Joy: Protecting the Heart of Christmas

  • Our Sarah: Made in Alaska

  • America by Heart: Reflections on Family, Faith, and Flag

  • Going Rogue: An American Life

  • Other Sarah Palin Info Sources

  • Login/RSS

  • Governor Palin on Twitter

  • @SarahPalinUSA

  • Governor Palin on Facebook

  • SarahPAC Notes

  • RSS SarahPAC Notes

    • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
  • SPWB on Facebook

  • SPWB on Twitter

  • @SarahPalinLinks

    Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

  • Join the SPWB Twibe!

  • Posts by Date

    November 2010
    S M T W T F S
    « Oct   Dec »
  • Categories

  • Archives

  • __________________________________________
  • Top Posts & Pages

  • __________________________________________
  • Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

  • __________________________________________

Columbia University; Rampant Elitism And Palin Derangement Syndrome

Posted by M.Joseph Sheppard At Palin4President2016 on November 11, 2010

The Columbia Journalism Review which describes itself as “Founded under the auspices of Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism” (not mentioning the advice that they are funded by Soros) and “in conversation with a community of people who share a commitment to high journalistic standards..” has decided to use those high standards to invest in a classic case of PDS.

In an oh so cleverly snarkily titled article “Sarah Palin, Media Critic” CJR takes Palin to task for “hyperbole” in daring to question the Wall Street Journals Sudeep Reddy for stating “grocery prices haven’t risen all that significantly”. Firstly Palin is acting as a commentator on economics-Bernanke’s QE2 money printing, which she described as misguided and inflationary, she is not acting as a “media critic”

The CJR author starts straight into the East Coast ivy league, ivory tower elitism-they just can’t resist it, it is like catnip and a sad and sorry spectacle. “Aw ,shucks” this representative of high journalistic standards commences his hit piece. He continues, “Sarah Palin is “just a former governor and current housewife from Alaska, bur even humble folks like (her) can read the newspaper.” Reading’s one thing. Comprehending’s another”. This is brilliant stuff at the Pulitzer level so far.

Lets see what Palin actually said and which thus determines who is indulging in hyperbole is. “Everyone who goes out shopping for groceries knows that prices have risen significantly over the past year or so.Pump priming would push them even higher.” Reddy in accusing Palin of hyperbole states that “Grocery prices haven’t risen all that significantly. Palin responded that in another article in the WSJ it was stated “Food Sellers Grit Teeth, Raise Prices…an inflationary tide is beginning to ripple through America’s supermarkets..prices of staples, including milk, beef, coffee, cocoa and sugar have risen sharply in recent months”

We see here the difference between an ivory tower economist and a person who can relate to the ordinary housewife. Grocery prices may have risen y.o.y. at 1.4% but that is a basket including non-staple items. Palin speaks to and for, especially, those who are out of work or who have not had a wage rise in a long time, will feel these rises strongly. Certainly much more strongly than e.g. a WSJ economist or the Editor of a prestigious ivy league journal.

The CJR even gets it wrong on their main premise-that Palin selectively quotes and misunderstands. They state “What the WSJ article said…is that food prices may be beginning to rise” Whereas the article said “An inflationary tide IS beginning to rise”. Perhaps they don’t teach the difference between “may “and “is” any more but to me the difference is quite clear.

They conclude by calling Palin out on her “ethics”, misquoting Reddy, and her having no right to condemn the media.They add insult to their own injury by ending with “Maybe they (Palin and a journalist) can talk about the possible wave of food inflation coming our way” That the editor is so blinded by PDS that he can’t understand what is a few paragraphs above his concluding snark “An inflationary tide IS beginning” shows how far the liberal elite have fal

What is it about New York that it is so blind to the reality of what is happening in the rest of the country? Certainly the city is depressed, when I was there in July I saw shop after shop closed, and the state has a budget crisis like most others. Yet with all that they elect two senators and their governor with majorities of up to 32%-they must think it is still 1936 or something.

There must be a unique blend of old line unionism, a financial liberal elite. Poverty struck minorities, who are tied to welfarism, or have not woken up to being kept in thrall by the propaganda of the elite, and are thus blind to the fact that minorities round America are fighting their way up and out of poverty by their boot straps.Thankfully New York appears to be the last bastion of this old line leftism and the state is declining in electoral college power being down to only 29 EC votes, the same as Florida. Once mighty NY was the king maker in presidential politics (as per Grover Cleveland’s two out of three) winning or losing it made you president or not, but that is nearing its end.

As for the esteemed intellectuals who commented on the CJR article, it is as expected. Intelligent, educated people summon up all their years of scholarship and advise pithily “She’s an idiot. Narcissistic personality disorder” and “Palin is a pathological liar…she has most of the hallmark symptoms of a sociopath” and etc. The ultimate indication of PDS elitism is “It is pretty obvious that she and her acolytes have never made it through Econ 101.That fact alone pretty much discredits any opinion she may have on economic matters”

Harry Truman, who never went to university and was a failed hat salesman, also never made it through Econ 101 unlike Obama/Carter and seemed to manage somehow. But that doesn’t fit with the world view of elitists who just don’t get it. They, and their Democratic Party, will certainly “get it” in 2012 as voters finish off what was started in 2010. But they won’t like what they will get when the great mass of plain folks show them they don’t like being condescended to.


6 Responses to “Columbia University; Rampant Elitism And Palin Derangement Syndrome”

  1. Joy said

    I’m reprinting what my uncle – a retired journalist, screenwriter and tv producer (who shares my political point of view!) – said in response to your excellent piece on the “fall” of the once-great New Yorker magazine:

    “I have waited years for that kind of article. I go back with the mag to 1940 when, in late teens, I read Esquire, Atlantic, Satevepost and all the mags…but the New Yorker was cool, wise, witty, restrained, thoughtful, adult, amusing, satiric… and I don’t remember it being political at all. I felt it was always just a good read and a balanced and often very funny mag.

    But about 20 years ago I couldn’t stand it and just quit going near it. That’s about when it became an exercrable rag, a cheap, shitty, narrow-minded and dishonest liberal hagiograph, a poltroon of stuffed cabbage, a sleaze bag and nonsense profligator.

    But what a fine article of condemnation that was! The truth is that Newsweek, CNN, even the lefty lib NY Times have all come on hard times. And the New Yorker is suffering deeply loss of readership. No wonder.

    But the conservative state of mind has at least substantially come into its own. Good. I liked the condemnation of the Palin aspect of the critique. It amazes me how stupid the anti-Ps really are! They’re just trying to wish away not just Palin, but the state of mind, with which they cannot compete.

    Love, N

  2. Joy said

    Hey, that was one of my father’s favorite lines (“just don’t call me late for dinner!”); but since it’s older than the hills and no copyright exists, it’s public domain by now! Thanks, Mike… JDB

  3. Joy said

    Thanks, MJS, for the encouraging words! (I tease my “fans” that their complimentary words are really “enabling” a dangerous “habit” of sitting at the ‘puter WAY too long and blogging away like a damn fool! Lol…)

    BTW, may I be so bold as to call you Joe or whatever given name by which others know you? MJS, however, is just peachy with me if that’s your preference!

    Thanks – and cheers!

  4. Thank you sincerely Joy.Your comment is bittersweet-highly appreciated but puts the pressure on to continue posting to the high standard which someone like you deserves :-). I’ll do my best driven on by the memory of your encouragement.
    Cordial regards.

  5. Joy said

    Mr. Sheppard, you’re becoming one of my new favorite bloggers – keep ’em coming! A better spokesman for Palin can only be found on this very same site (lol…). I love your take on things and the fact that you’re a New Yorker (or were), born & bred; so, you see what’s happened to it and what’s going on – thanks in no small measure to the idiot lib[didacted] elites! And WAY too many of them, of course, are Trust Fund Babies who couldn’t run a lemonade stand without Daddy & Mommy’s gazillions that they were lucky enough to inherit (too bad they held on to some of it, too, ‘else we’d hear a lot less from them!).

    Meantime, my hat’s off to you for putting yourself through what I would call torture: Reading the Soros-backed Columbia Journalism Review (CJR). I simply cannot stand to read Lib[didacted]Speak – it’s painful, boring, predictable and nauseating. And yes, it just proves that an Ivy League education is no guarantee that the graduate will emerge with a better education that those who graduate from, say, the Univ. of Idaho! I’m developing as much armour as I can, however, by still volunteering for my own alma mater (one of what they used to call the Seven – now Six – Sister Colleges), which is seeped in LiberalSpeak (although there are some genuinely outstanding students & alumnae who are NOT lawyers or working for the Welfare State or on Capitol Hill!). It will be interesting to see how these mostly liberal elites react when Palin is a serious contender in 2012 – UNLESS Hillary decides to challenge NObama!! (Although Hillary doesn’t have all that much viable political time left – she’ll be pushing or at 70 in 2016!)

    And, finally, I must challenge you on your statement about New Yorkers voting in another set of Dem losers: California holds that honor West of the Mississippi! We have Moonbeam back to finish the job he started 30 years ago (with those destructive union & public employee pensions) – i.e., attempting to bankrupt the state once & for all! The Golden State has turned to dross and is all copper-greenish to boot!

    Looking foward to your nest vivisection of the American Left and its offspring, lil’ ol’ PDS…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: